Saturday, December 9, 2017

UN Appeals Tribunal rules on unlawful actions by Pension Board, 10 December 2017



On 27 October 2017, the UN Appeals Tribunal ruled that the actions of the UN Pension Board to block two elected UN participant representatives from the  Board were unlawful (UNAT Judgment No. 2017-UNAT-807; Rockcliffe (Appellant) v.United Nations Joint Staff Pension Board (Respondent); Counsel for Appellant: George G. Irving; Counsel for Respondent: Sergio B. Arvizú, and Judgment No. 2017-UNAT-801; Faye (Appellant) v. United Nations Joint Staff Pension Board (Respondent); Counsel for Appellant: self-represented; Counsel for Respondent: Sergio B. Arvizú, links below to the judgments).

Recall that two recent internal audits of the Fund secretariat conducted by the UN Office of Internal Oversight Services and completed in October 2017, revealed disturbing findings about lax controls and management in the Fund secretariat as CEO Sergio Arvizu’s five-year contract nears its end on 31 December 2017 (Nos. 2017/104, 2017/110). 

UNAT's ruling is further indication that for the sake of the Fund, Arvizu must go and that the Board, which lacks oversight and transparency, is in need of reform. The Board appears to have ignored OIOS audit 2017/02 on the backlog in pension payments in pushing for a three-year contract extension for Arvizu at its July meeting. It then hopped on board a claim of conflict of interest posited by the Fund's Chief, Risk Management and Legal Services (para. 3 of the judgment) backed by Arvizu --related to a 1992 legal opinion which had never been put into effect and which UNAT found to be baseless -- to try to block the two duly elected participant representatives from the Board.  


In the Fund secretariat, the buck stops with Arvizu, but a triumvirate of senior managers shares responsibility for mismanagement detailed in OIOS audits and other reports, and must all be held accountable, including for the recent rejection by the UN Board of Auditors of the actuarial valuation for 2017 because of unreliable data provided by the Fund --yet another managerial mishap on which the Board failed to exercise its oversight role. 

Quote from the Rockcliffe judgment, identical to the Faye Judgment : “It is the ruling of the Appeals Tribunal that Ms. Rockcliffe as a duly elected member of the UNSPC has the same rights and privileges which are bestowed on other UNSPC members and she ought not to be denied those rights. We therefore order that Ms. Rockcliffe is granted access to all relevant Pension Board documents. We further order that she is allowed to participate and function as an elected member to the UNSPC in all relevant areas including the preparations for the Pension Board sessions and meetings and its constituent groups, committees and working groups.”

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

Long overdue: A new boss at the UN Pension Fund and a reformed Board, 15 November 2017










An important change was made to the United Nations pension fund last month, when Secretary-General António Guterres announced he was appointing Sudhir Rajkumar of India to succeed Carol Boykin as his representative for investments of the $61.5 billion fund.
Guterres needs to make another major change, however, to address serious problems at the joint staff pension fund. Two recent UN internal audits detail irregularities in procurement and contracts in the fund’s secretariat, headed by Sergio Arvizu, the chief executive officer. Many fund observers inside and outside the UN consider these new developments not only more indication that Arvizu must go, but also that the pension board needs to improve its oversight and requires structural reform.
READ FULL ARTICLE HERE:

Friday, November 10, 2017

Pension Fund: UN audit finds $1.8 million in unauthorized spending, 10 November 2017



AT UN PENSION FUND, WITH $1.8 MILLION IN UNAUTHORIZED SPENDING, SG GUTERRES TO KEEP ARVIZU? 

Nov 9 at 11:47am
By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive Series
UNITED NATIONS, November 9 – With UN Pension Fund problems including late payments and $3.4 billion in foreign exchange costs leading to the departure of Secretary General Antonio Guterres' representative to the Fund Carolyn Boykin, who issued a gag order to staff not to leak to Inner City Press, problems remain. On Halloween we first wrote of Boykin's replaced Sudhir Rajkumar, triggering much feedback into which, despite the restrictions and threats by Guterres' Department of Public Information, we are digging.
Now this: a UN Office of Internal Oversight Service audit has found at least $1.8 million in unauthorized spending, and much PCW work being done outside the contours of the agreed contract, at higher cost to the UN. We've put the audit online, here below, on Patreon, with these questions: [SEE LINK BELOW]
How much pension fund money was overspent on the 75 percent of services that were not bid for? (If there had been bidding for the other services, there may have been less use of $475 an hour partners. Having signed a contract for low-cost accountancy services, how did PWC accept to provide high-cost consultancy services without a new contract being signed? Was there collusion between PWC and Pension Fund staff? Doesn't the buck stop with, or in this case flow from, the CEO?
And this: the six UN Participant Representatives have asked Guterres to NOT reappoint the current CEO of the pension fund, Sergio Arvizu. We've published the letter on Patreon, here. Already, the Board has proposed only a three year and not a five year reappoint. The six UN Participant Representatives say it should be zero, based on: "a poorly implemented new IT system with no contingency planning, leaving retirees without income, many for more than nine months; attempts, since blocked by the General Assembly, to remove OIOS as the Fund’s auditor; attempts to remove the Fund from the UN’s administrative oversight by creating new staff and financial rules; attempts to circumvent rules on procurement and receiving gifts.
It should be noted that the current payment backlog to widows, orphans and retirees still numbers in the thousands. For almost three years the CEO has refused to meet with staff representatives at the Fund despite multiple attempts by staff. The CEO has misrepresented good faith and constructive efforts made by the UN’s Department of Management to resolve the situation involving two staff of the Fund’s Secretariat elected to the Board." On this last, the "UN Appeals Tribunal last week ruled illegal a decision by the pension fund’s board to exclude two of the six members that you, as UN staff, elected back in April."
We'll have more on this, and on what Guterres does."

LINK TO REPORT HERE (SCROLL DOWN TO 2017/110 ON THE LIST ON THE OIOS WEBSITE):

https://oios.un.org/page?slug=report


Friday, October 27, 2017

UN Appeals Tribunal rules that CEO's ban on elected UN representatives is illegal, 27 October 2017




Message from the UN Participant Representatives to the Pension Board, 27 October 2017

"UN APPEALS TRIBUNAL RULES ELECTED UN REPRESENTATIVES CANNOT BE EXCLUDED FROM PENSION FUND BOARD
We are pleased to inform you that the UN Appeals Tribunal today ruled illegal a decision by pension fund CEO Sergio Arvizu to ban two elected staff representatives, Michelle Rockcliffe and Ibrahima Faye, from the fund's board.
The tribunal found there was no legal provision to back the CEO's actions.
For memory, the two representatives were banned despite being among the six successful candidates in the UN's staff pension committee elections in April, at which 18,000 staff voted.
The motivation behind the CEO's actions are impossible to know. But Michelle and Ibrahima's inside knowledge of the fund and its leadership could well have been embarrassing at the board following the mishandling of the new IT system during which newly retiring staff went up to 6 months without being paid, and a more recent incident during which incorrect data was given to the fund's actuaries.
The UNAT judgement vindicates the 4,500 staff who signed a petition protesting the ban and the staff unions, who through CCISUA staff federation, launched the legal appeal.
At the same time it shines a light on the legal and moral vacuum within the pension fund's leadership. To this end, the staff unions have made clear to UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres that Arvizu should not be extended when his contract comes up for renewal at the end of this year. A new leadership is needed.
Here is a picture of the six UN participant representatives. Now we can sit together next time the board meets, and represent and defend the interests of 80,000 UN staff and its many retirees.
Thank you all for your support!"

Thursday, October 19, 2017

UN Pension Fund: New Representative of the Secretary-General for Investments, 19 October 2017




THE FIRST WAVE OF NEEDED CHANGE AND HOPE IT'S GOOD FOR OUR FUND (Recall that the World Bank -- he's head of the global pension advisory programme at the World Bank -- according to the Fund CEO's public statement, joined large organizations that changed from defined benefit to defined contribution plan. But let's take a step back, welcome the change and give him a chance.)
UN SPOKESPERSON'S OFFICE
NEW RSG FOR THE UN PENSION FUND
"Secretary-General appoints Sudhir Rajkumar of India
as his Representative for United Nations Joint Staff Pension Fund Asset Investments
United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres announced today the appointment of Sudhir Rajkumar of India as Representative of the Secretary-General for the investment of the assets of the United Nations Joint Staff Pension Fund. He will succeed Carol Boykin of the United States to whom the Secretary-General is grateful for her commitment and dedicated service to the Organization.
Mr. Rajkumar brings to the position more than twenty-eight years of broad-based global investment experience, covering formulation and implementation of investment policies, and hands-on experience with global bond markets, private equity and project finance transactions, and corporate finance and privatization advisory engagements.
He is currently head of the global pension advisory programme at the World Bank Treasury, a role in which he has provided advisory services to the National Pension Fund of the Republic of Korea, Ministry of Finance of Brunei Darussalam, South Africa’s Government Employees Pension Fund, KWAP - Malaysia's second largest pension fund and the Nazarbayev University Endowment in Kazakhstan – in addition to other public investment institutions globally. He also currently serves as a member on the External Advisory Committee on Investments of the Food and Agriculture Organization, the Investment Committee of the United Nations Office for Project Services, and as Vice-Chair of the Board of Directors of the International Centre for Pension Management (ICPM).
Mr. Rajkumar began his career at the World Bank in Eastern Africa Operations as a Young Professional in 1988. Since then, he has worked in various regions and capacities with the World Bank and International Finance Corporation, including as Principal Investment Officer. Prior to this, he served in managerial positions with the Shriram Group in New Delhi and Kota, India.
Mr. Rajkumar holds a Master of Business Administration from the University of Chicago, a Master of Science in Economics from the London School of Economics and a Bachelor of Science in Engineering from the University of Delhi. He is co-editor and an author of the book Governance and Investment of Public Pension Assets: Practitioners’ Perspectives published by the World Bank.
New York, 19 October 2017"

Friday, September 29, 2017

Bloomberg: UN Pension Fund Starts Search For New Management, 29 September 2017

UN's $61 Billion Pension Fund Starts Search for New Management


  • September 29, 2017, 4:00 AM EDT
  • ‘Trump bump’ in market may have come too late to save managers
  • Fund makes payments in 15 currencies to UN retirees worldwide
The UN Joint Staff Pension Fund is seeking candidates with “more than 20 years of proven progressively responsible experience” to replace Carolyn Boykin, the former chief investment officer of the Maryland State Retirement and Pension System, who took the UN post three years ago, according to an internal job posting seen by Bloomberg News.
Whoever replaces Boykin won’t be taking a typical investment post. The UN fund is among the world’s most complex, with more than 128,000 participants and 72,000 retirees in nearly 200 countries. Its payments go out in 15 currencies, including dollars, euros, kroners and rupees.
While the fund is up about 12 percent this year through August -- in line with the S&P 500’s return -- to a record $61 billion, that gain from the “Trump bump” in markets has come too late. At the famously byzantine UN, the posting of Boykin’s job is an unusual sign of disapproval from Guterres, who took office in January and oversees the pension fund’s investment director.
“Officially her post was advertised, but that’s UN for firing,” said Ian Richards, a critic of Boykin who serves as president of the Coordinating Committee for International Staff Unions and Associations of the UN system, the employee labor union, which has more than 60,000 members.

‘Competitive Process’

Calls to Boykin’s office seeking comment were directed to the secretary-general’s office.
“She is aware that nominations for her post have been opened,” said Farhan Haq, deputy spokesman for the secretary-general. “The position was advertised widely and will be filled through a competitive evaluation process.”
The decision to seek new leadership comes after the fund had an inflation-adjusted return of 3.1 percent last year, missing its own target by 0.4 percentage points. That miss wasn’t a one-off. The pension fund also missed its target by 5.2 percentage points in 2015 and by 1 percentage point the year before.
Boykin isn’t the only manager who has faced criticism. Sergio Arvizu, the fund’s chief executive officer who oversees benefits and operations, came under fire after new benefits-management software installed in 2015 led to delays in making payments to beneficiaries. Thousands of new retirees, some of whom had to wait six months to receive payments, were enraged.
Matters came to a head last December, when the General Assembly passed a resolution criticizing the fund’s returns and for the delays in making payments. The resolution expressed concern that, for the 2014–2015 period, the fund had “losses” of $3.4 billion in foreign exchange transactions.

Audit Conducted

The resolution also called on the UN Office of Internal Oversight Services to conduct comprehensive audits of the fund’s policies and report on Boykin’s performance.
The subsequent audit criticized management for not developing plans on how to eliminate delays and expedite hiring for long-vacant positions. The report also urged steps to ensure that delays and “very low response” rates to emails and telephone calls from clients be addressed.
Boykin, who was previously president of Bolton Partners Investment Consulting Group, is part of a complex governance structure at the UN fund. While Boykin reports directly to Guterres, Arvizu oversees benefits and operations and reports directly to the UN General Assembly, the main body representing all 193 member countries. The investment committee includes representatives from China, Germany, Iraq, Botswana, Spain, Brazil and the U.S.
Arvizu, a former director of investments at Mexico’s Social Security Institute, has also been a target of the UN’s labor union over efforts to change management policies at the fund. In a 2015 letter to members, Arvizu said he was facing a “malicious campaign with gross misrepresentations.” The allegations triggered an internal investigation by the UN’s anti-corruption watchdog, which cleared Arvizu.
The latest General Assembly resolution also had an impact on Arvizu’s contract negotiations. He already had served one five-year term and was eligible for a second five-year term starting in 2018. But the pension board renewed his contract for three years instead.
“The consensus was for a three-year extension,” Lee Woodyear, a spokesman for Arvizu, said in a phone interview. “There were some compromises.”

Monday, September 25, 2017

UN Pension Fund: Selection of the RSG for Investments: Open letter to the USG for Management, 25 September 2017

Open letter to Ms. Jan Beagle, United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Management

25 September 2017

Dear Ms. Beagle,

Subject: Selection for the post of Representative of the Secretary-General for Investments

In view of the current selection process for the Fund’s Representative of the Secretary-General for Investments (RSG), it is imperative that you ensure that the selection committee bears the following pertinent information in mind.

As you are aware, investment underperformance – failure to meet the policy benchmark – puts the long-term sustainability of the Fund at risk and is a matter of ongoing concern.  

The issues are documented in the reports of UN governing bodies and include General Assembly resolution 71/625, reports of the Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions (A/72/621), the Board of Auditors for the past two years (A/71/5.Add.16 and A/72/5.Add.16) and the report of the 63rd Pension Board meeting (A/71/9).  In fact, this matter has been of such concern that the Pension Board this year engaged Deloitte Touche to perform an independent third-party review of investments.